I just received my first subscription box. Im not sure if shipping was slow because of the holiday, but I also like instant gratification. I like that there was a mix of product sizes - some sample so I dont get stuck with things I dont like and some full size so I dont feel scammed. I just received it today and played with a couple things I got. They seem good quality. The eye pencil arrived broken, though, so that was a bummer. Its still usable but disappointing to received damaged goods. I'm giving 4 stars for now since that may have been a USPS thing. I look forward to my next box!